I've been up in the air about this show. The heroine is quirky, charming and annoying at times. The lie detector gimmick is dumb, and it seems to be fading. The plots are like recycled "Colombo".That said the last episode about the 60's radicals took me by complete surprise. It started out like a cliche then took a wicked turn. If They keep doing episodes like that (and tone down the human lie detector) I'll be a fan.
Yeah the human lie detector thing is def. an interesting gimmick, and I too am kinda hoping that now we're into the series it fades a bit (or is at least relatively subtle, where she's not constantly saying 'BS'). As for Columbo, that seems to be the point: the real difference, IMO, being Columbo seemed to thrive with its class warfare ethos. I haven't seen every episode (or movie? IDK what to consider Columbo's. movie-of-the-month format), but every one I have seen involves Columbo busting very rich folks: famous authors, art dealers, retired Generals, etc. With the exception of the Poker Face 'big bad' being the casino, this feels straight-up like working class-working class crime so far. This is definitely a series I appreciate watching once a week and not binging.